Posted by: Mark Stoneman on: July 30, 2008
Looking back, I am surprised at how easy it was for me to get through high school and many college courses without knowing a lot of basic vocabulary related to English grammar. I knew English grammar intuitively, and I could write, but I could not talk about grammar. I am lucky I knew enough intuitively, for this weakness could have become a real handicap for me in my studies.
In fact, it did become a weakness in one subject: Russian. We had to take a foreign language at Dartmouth College, and I fulfilled the requirement with Russian. But I was horrible. I do not believe that I ever rose above a C+. Part of the problem was study habits and discipline, but much of it related to my lack of appreciation of the nature of grammar. The professors used terms like genitive case, dative case, direct object, personal pronoun, possessive pronoun, conjugate, and decline, and it seemed like I had to devote too much energy to understanding that vocabulary and the things it indicated instead of learning Russian. Or I missed points entirely because I did not recognize their significance.
I only appreciated this dilemma later, after I took a break from Dartmouth and came back. During my time away I was in the army and stationed in Germany, where I learned to get by with rudimentary German. Upon returning to Dartmouth I decided I would like to learn German properly. My experience was enhanced considerably by a practical little book by Cecile Zorach entitled English Grammar for Students of German. It explained the way English grammar worked for certain situations and then compared it to German. It was through these comparisons that I began to gain an appreciation of the mechanics of English grammar and a vocabulary with which to talk about it. This knowledge later served me well when I found myself in Munich teaching English to Germans. Of course, the learning process never ended.
In this new series, I intend to share basic vocabulary of grammar so that I can use it when trying to explain various things. For example, today I actually wanted to write about the correct and incorrect usage of who and whom, but I found myself talking about direct and indirect objects, and I realized I had to lay a little groundwork first. This is the beginning.
- – - – - – - – - – - – - – -
By the way, English Grammar for Students of German is part of a series that also includes titles for students of Arabic, French, Italian, Latin, and Russian. To learn more, visit the my online bookstore and choose the “English Grammar for Foreign Languages” category.
I am exactly the same Mark! I went to a state comprehensive in the Seventies… on the whole it was appalling where English was concerned. I don’t remember being taught any of the more complex grammar except though my German lessons and frankly I had no idea what the teacher was talking about! Full stops and commas, metaphors and similes during English lessons were as good as it got! Those days were bad ones in the education system in the UK. Unfortunately, things haven’t got any better; some of our universities are now teaching Maths and English as foundation courses because the standard is so poor on entrance. There are also currently 7 million adults in the UK with inadequate standards of Maths and English and that figure is rocketing every year.
The government is trying to combat these figures by encouraging adults to attend literacy and numeracy courses either through independent free courses or through employers. They have introduced new exams for adult learners which are supposed to on a par with the school GCSE system and recognisable by employers. However, it is laughable. (I have done some training in this area.) An adult can obtain the equivalent of a GSCE by sitting a multiple choice exam about 1 hour long. They are not even required to write a sentence! It is sheer and utter madness. It is just an illusion of wellbeing.
Like you, I have been blessed with an intuitive knowledge of grammar enhanced by an addiction to reading from a very young age. My love of books was an education in itself and without them I would never got through the state system successfully.
The degeneration of the English is a real sore point with me. Even though I occasionally lapse from the rules on my blog (cough, cough) I like to think I can communicate well. I wonder where society will be in 50 years time? It doesn’t bear thinking about.
If your interested, here’s a rare serious post of mine on language and literacy.
http://janeturleydiaryofamadhousewife.blogspot.com/2008/01/life-and-language-personal-story.html
Thank you. I’ll be reading. I am very much into Latin roots and usually can figure out most things that I don’t easily understand. However, I like the way you write and will be following this line very closely. Thanks again for your unselfish sharing – Nards
Fantastic. Your writing has given me inspiration. Thanks.
Comments are closed.
July 30, 2008 at 10:50 am
I’m looking forward to your future posts in this series. There’s nothing like learning a foreign language to help you understand the grammar of your own. Latin did for me what German did for you. you can’t understand how to build the correct word if you don’t understand the terms governing the the prefixes and suffixes.